Front Page/History First Alarm: Garnerville 1854 Posted on July 23, 2016 by Bart FIRST ALARM The first fire attended by the company was to Garnerville N.Y. on September 7th, 1854. It involved a barn a little west of the Garner home, what is now 18 Railroad Avenue. 2016, First Call, GARNERVILLE, Havertraw, R C V F A, September 7th Bart View all posts by Bart →